Your Succession Plan Is a List of Names. It Should Be a List of Handoffs.

Your Succession Plan Is a List of Names. It Should Be a List of Handoffs.

Your Succession Plan Is a List of Names. It Should Be a List of Handoffs.

At the 2008 Beijing Olympics, both American 4×100 relay teams dropped the baton and were eliminated before the final. Some of the fastest sprinters on earth were beaten on a stretch of track just a few strides long.

Everyone in business talks about passing the baton. That is the wrong half of the race. A relay is rarely lost when the runner lets go. It is lost when the runner receiving it isn’t already up to speed.

Senior promotions fail the same way, in two directions at once. The leader you promote must take the baton from above. Someone behind that leader must be running at full speed to take the baton. Most organizations plan the first handoff. Almost none plan the second.

A list of names is not a plan

Look at your succession plan. It names who moves up. It rarely names who moves into the seat that person leaves, or whether that successor is ready now or later.

In 2025, Korn Ferry found that only 10% of CEOs and directors are extremely confident their C-suite will thrive. That is not a talent shortage. It is a release problem. The talent is in the building. It was never brought up to speed because the leader holding the baton never had to let go.

Which is why your strongest leader may be your biggest succession risk. The SVP who walks into every crisis, knows every number, and answers the CEO’s 10 p.m. email in four minutes looks like the obvious successor. But if the business runs through that leader, it doesn’t run without them. Promote them, and you open two holes. The seat they leave, which nobody can fill. And the seat they take, where the habits that made them indispensable now slow everyone down.

Promotion is decided in two directions.

The people above need to see a leader who will take the business somewhere new. The people below need to be ready to take the seat. Miss either one, and the promotion fails, no matter how talented the leader is.

Most executive coaching works in one direction. It sharpens how the leader is perceived upstairs and ignores whether anyone downstairs can run the next leg. That is training a sprinter who can’t pass the baton.

Predictable Promotion® works both ways. I learned both directions the only way you can, from the inside, by climbing about a dozen rungs over 26 years at one Fortune 100 company. That is how most C-suites are still built: Spencer Stuart’s 2025 data shows that 59% of S&P 500 C-suite leaders and 76% of CEOs came from within. At every level I climbed, the lesson was the same. A leader’s ability to win the next seat depends 100% on the team earning theirs.

Promote what they no longer carry

Stop promoting leaders for how much they personally carry. Start promoting them for how much they no longer need to carry.

That changes what you measure. Not the leader’s results, but the team’s results when the leader is out for two weeks. Not how many decisions the leader makes, but how many the direct reports make in the leader’s absence. Not whether the leader is ready, but whether anyone behind the leader is.

Make that the rule, out loud, and the incentives flip. Leaders stop hoarding the hard work and start handing it off because the handoff is what gets them promoted.

Ready means still climbing two years later.

Most organizations judge a promotion on the day it is announced. The org chart is updated, the congratulations email goes out, and the file is closed.

That is the start of the leg, not the finish. Predictable Promotion® was never about the next rung on the ladder. It is about what happens once the leader is standing on that rung: succeeding in the seat, sustaining it, and still climbing two years later, with someone else climbing into the seat behind them.

A Fortune 500 SVP I partnered with was given six months to earn a promotion. He became an EVP in four months and has since been appointed CEO twice. Nearly ten years later, we are still working together, and he is still climbing.

That is the only definition of readiness that matters to the organization paying for it. Heidrick & Struggles has long reported that four in ten senior leaders fail or leave within 18 months of a promotion. That failure never appears as a single line item. It appears as a stalled division, a high potential who resigned after waiting too long, and a search firm invoice for a seat you thought you had filled.

Before your next announcement

Pick the leader you plan to promote within the next 12 months. Then name the person who takes their seat on the day they move.

If you can’t name one, you don’t have a promotion. You have a baton about to hit the track.

Two years from now, will you be congratulating that leader on their next move or interviewing their replacement?

No Comments

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.